The constituent assembly tasked with
drafting Egypt's post-revolution constitution has passed the document as the
country continues to reel from a decree that gave extraordinary powers to the
president, the Muslim Brotherhood's Mohamed Morsi.
The assembly, hit by walkouts from minority
groups and liberal voices opposed to Islamist domination, worked through the
night after the absent members were replaced and voting commenced on the
document article by article.
The draft had been criticised for its
ambiguous language on human rights, minority rights and freedom of expression,
as well as its concentration on enshrining sharia law as the basis for
legislature. It also protects army privileges that revolutionary forces want
rescinded, including the ability to try civilians in military courts.
The draft must now be put to a nationwide
referendum within 30 days. Morsi said the vote would be held "soon".
The Islamist-dominated assembly that has
been working on the constitution for months raced to pass it, voting article by
article on the draft's more than 230 articles for more than 16 hours. Of the 85
members in attendance, there was not a single Christian and only four women.
Articles that were passed included one
prohibiting the insult or slander of any person, which could prove troublesome
for free speech. However, the rights of expression, the press and belief were
included and passed. The right of religious practice was also included, but
extended only to Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Article 36 included an 11th-hour addition
of the word "torture" in the article regarding treatment of
detainees. Initially the article had stipulated that detainees should be
treated "with respect" and not "humiliated".
"The Muslim Brotherhood can succeed in
passing this constitution despite the opposition but in so doing they are
likely to poison the country's political atmosphere for years to come and my
assumption is that the constitution, if passed, will not survive beyond
Brotherhood rule," said Elijah Zarwan, a Cairo-based fellow at the
European Council for Foreign Relations.
Egypt has been plunged into a
constitutional crisis since a self-issued decree by Morsi gave him sweeping
powers and immunity from judicial challenges. The decree also granted the
constituent assembly immunity from legal challenges, which were already under
way and expected to be decided in December.
Morsi's extraordinary powers will remain in
effect until a constitution is passed and a parliament is elected, and while
the decree gave the assembly a two-month extension on its work, the decision to
finalise and vote on the document within two days has led to criticism that the
job is being rushed to temper the outcry.
Morsi was due to address the nation later
today, calling for unity and support for his decree, which he insists is merely
a temporary measure to ensure that the constituent assembly can continue its
work without threat of dissolution by the Egyptian courts.
If the constitution is rejected at
referendum, it is then returned to the same assembly for redrafting and Morsi
will keep his powers.
And that might be Morsi's play, according
to Zarwan, who said that people might be more willing to accept the
constitution in order to put an end to the decree. "For a lot of people
they'll say, 'Let's just get on with it.'"
No comments:
Post a Comment